why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner

House Baratheon of Storm's End Still, other fans think Cersei and Jaime Lannister (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) were responsible for bringing Jaqen to Kings Landing. Content must be relevant. There is a part in the series when Jaqen says "There is only one God. Sie suchen nach einem Game of thrones book 2, das Ihren Ansprchen gerecht wird? Meanwhile, in Braavos, Arya begins learning the secrets of the Faceless Men of Braavos, a feared order of mysterious assassins. She went to the House of Black and white and met and old man. InA Song of Ice and Fire, many break the law of fairness and among them is Jaqen, a man with no identity, a perfect weapon. We also do not get to actually see the fight between Arya and the Waif that ends with Arya hanging the Waif's face in the Hall of Faces. Just like in the books, Arya blackmailed Jaqen by naming him. Arya Stark first met Jaqen H'ghar all the way back in Season 1 when he was a strange prisoner of the Lannisters. As part of their deal, Arya agreed to help him with three tasks, and she accomplished them all. Others Why do the Tyrells come to King's Landing? And also because he knew Arya's real identity. The second person Arya requested was Weese for beating her. Jaquen mission is to obtain a key to a room in the citadel from a Maester. Copyright 2023 Endgame360 Inc. All Rights Reserved. "We have The Waif coming in because so many people think that Arya . plays a major role in Arya's journey in Season 5, was him being captured in Kings Landing unrelated, or. Beyond the Wall He already repayed his debt to her, so he would not be completing her list as a gift, and he is probably not seeking revenge on his former captors the Lannisters since he does not seem like the type to hold a grudge. The fan speculation that Jaqen is Syrio Forel is based mostly on wishful thinking, as there is no evidence of that, other than the fact that Syrio might have been captured and Jaqen appears in the black cells at around the same time. It is not accurate to believe that Jaqen H'ghar is the only Faceless Man there is. Chiswyck was killed by his own dog. However, the gold coin was poisoned, and when pate bit into it, he died. Unfortunately, its unclear when the final book will be released or when fans will understand the origins of Jaqen HGhar. Jaqen H'ghar is one of the most mysterious characters on "Game Of Thrones." In both the show and the books, Jaqen meets Arya Stark while he is an imprisoned criminal headed for the Wall . There is only some indirect evidence: Yoren tells Arya that he was told in advance that Ned would be taking the black, and bribed to stay in King's Landing longer. And while I'd like him to be Syrio Forel (and he's not shown to die) I believe he is dead. Despite how insane and savage Rorge and Biter were, they were afraid of Jaqen. Privacy Policy. Arya died during her Faceless Men training. Has that ever been alluded to? why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner. Jaqen later leaves Arya as she heads to meet her brother and sister. We don't know of anyone who fits this description, but it's not exactly vital to the story either. Petyr Baelish Ygritte Syrio = Jaqen. Jaqen explained how the Faceless Men originated from slaves in Valyria. The prisoner lifted an empty tankard, his chains rattling. Osney Kettleblack I'm pretty sure Jaquen only worships Death, Death is the many faced god. I think they mention that they price so that anyone can afford them, but so that it's ruinously expensive and a major sacrifice for everyone. I don't think it's ever discussed. It is not explained in the books, but there is mention of him in AFFC, I believe, when a prison guard mentions that there were three men in the black cells. We still dont know what his secret Those people need to be killed in order for everybody else to unite. Hosteen Frey | The Lannisters didn't really need Ned dead, they just wanted to keep the North in line. Arya refused to be no one and stated she was Arya of House Stark. It makes a lot of sense - as a traitor, Ned would of course be put into the cage with the other criminals. It's awfully convenient that Mr. H'ghar, a Braavosi man who typically resides in the House of Black and White, runs into Arya Stark. The bulk of these theories suggest that Arya died during her Faceless Men training in Braavos, and that the Arya on the show now is actually someone else in disguise. Whoever the author.Discover new and exciting books to dive into with our Book Explorer Tool. Arya edged backward away from the wagon. Janos Slynt | Other than that, enjoy Villains Wiki!!! Since Arya saved three lives, Jaqen told Arya he would kill three people for her. Jaqen wears a tattered garb that smells and is filthy; this is because he got imprisoned in the black cells of the Red Keep. When she escaped Winterfell and took on the alias of Arry, Jaqen already saw that Arya was a survivor who would adapt and blend with her environment. Well, that's for the end of the essay. He later meets her and reveals he knows she is a girl. Jaime Lannister | Secondly the Faceless Men are extremely expensive and they wouldn't waste the cash on someone they regard as politically naive. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. However, the people he killed were different. Mandon Moore | The content on Book Analysis was created by Game of Thrones fans, with the aim of providing a thorough in-depth analysis and commentary to complement and provide an additional perspective to the incredible world George R.R. Brotherhood without Banners Xaro Xhoan Daxos, Far East Essos This is a place to enjoy and discuss the HBO series, book series ASOIAF, and GRRM works in general. In the books, that particular no-one has a very different trajectory to Braavos, and is almost certainly last seen (mystery spoiler in AFFC) impersonating a dead Citadel acolyte, "befriending" Sam, having killed a seemingly innocent young man to acquire an Archmaester's key. February 6, 2022 junctional nevus histology on why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner junctional nevus histology on why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner As I say, I don't think it is necessarily illogical that a faceless man might be caught and held captive in such circumstances. Axell Florent | I think that Jaqen was a creature of Varys and was in there for some reason that Varys needed him to be. Styr | But in which way exactly their story is going to continue? It would be totally f*'d up if it will be revealed that Jaqen was in fact a guest of Varys, and he was hired to remove the Hand of the King from his position. Stormlands Does this hint at an alternative explanation for an early death - or is it just GRRM being lazy, and needing a way to introduce him and and immediately establish him as a DANGEROUS CHARACTER. Faith Militant MY guess is he got caught on his way to Old Town and serendipity made him interact with Arya. rev2023.3.1.43269. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. I am an admin of this site. Applications of super-mathematics to non-super mathematics. For more information, please see our Raymund Frey | He gets arrested to access Varys, who has access to the Black Cells. It's highly unlikely that a Faceless Man would allow himself to be captured after an assassination, and most of their assassinations were designed to look like accidents anyway. So my point is that whatever he was trying to do, going to the wall probably wasn't part of the plan. Cersei Lannister, the Mountain, Walder Frey. Murder Of course there was no plan to recruit Arya: just look at the impossible chain of events, including the rolling prison catching fire and Arya saving them. Pycelle | However, Ser Armory Lorch leads an attack against them and kills Yoren. Balon Greyjoy | Arya continues working at Harrenhal and develops a hatred for some people. House Arryn House Frey Ellaria Sand | Euron Greyjoy | Was Galileo expecting to see so many stars? Jaqen H'ghar from Game of Thrones is obviously a ninja-like fighter and has shown his incredible skills. Little Walder Frey | It gets revealed that he is a messenger of death, a Faceless Man. Hugh Hammer | Larys Strong We know very little of the man in general, but here is what we know from the books: Based on these three things, we can speculate that he had assumed the Jaqen face & identity in order to assassinate someone in King's Landing. The first person Arya requested was Chiswyck, after hearing that he, along with the Mountain's Men, participated in a gang rape. He was taken to by Yoren to be a member of the Night's Watch. A man's gifts are not to be regifted. He is an enigmatic assassin belonging to the Faceless Men, a death cult based in the free city of Braavos. quite easily manage alone. Doreah | To leave Westeros, Arya shows the iron coin to Ternesio Terys, a Braavosi sailor, and says: Valar Morghulis. Terys responds: Valar Dohaeris and Arya gets on the ship headed to Braavos. Thomas Wlaschiha is a German actor. Do Syrio Forel, Jaqen H'ghar and Melisandre all follow the same religion? Because of their shared abilities, it could be possible, and it might explain Arya's changed temperament since returning from Braavos. The Vale of Arryn Who Is Jaqen H'Ghar? Arya was a lost lamb for a bit, what with her dead family and all, and maybe in this case, the Faceless Man was trying to remind Arya of her face. (Game of Thrones, ASOIAF) In Deep Geek 530K subscribers Join Subscribe 4.9K Share Save 300K views 5 years ago What was Jaqen H'ghar doing in the Black. Is Koestler's The Sleepwalkers still well regarded? Wait a second @Ward Actually, I wish him dead! This is not a site for fan speculation; as a Q&A site answers are expected to be of good quality and backed up by sources. Jaqen later meets Arya Stark after she escapes from Kings Landing and changes her appearance. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Occupation And why does the Many-Faced God make people nameless just to murder people for money? Viserion, Kang the Conqueror (Marvel Cinematic Universe). Like someone had hired him to kill Ned, but then he didn't get the chance? Rattleshirt | Yoren takes him to the Wall. Blood and Cheese | He was being kept in The Black Cells, which are reserved for the worst criminals. Arya states she wants Ser Amory, and he dies from a poisoned dart. Tags. This indicates that he is either extremely violent or a political liability for someone important. Gerold Dayne | By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Press J to jump to the feed. That doesn't really make sense to me. He had charge of the Melisandre | Truce of the burning tree -- how realistic? Aerion Targaryen | Vhagar | It only takes a minute to sign up. From there, Jaqen talks to Varys, knows who to kill and why, and only needs to find a way to escape from Yoren before they get to the wall. This suggests, Jaqen was essentially Varys's prisoner - or his guest. The Weeper | Balerion | Also note Jaqen wasn't caught by Yoren (the Night's Watch "recruiter"), but was already locked in a cell of the Red Keep at King's Landing. Varys | The North I feel that Varys is a Faceless Man as well and Jaqen was sent to meet with Varys to find out what his duties were. It almost seems like he found her in order to help her. Smiling Knight, Essos Brave companion, feckless acolyte with master key, beggar, snack seller Where better in KL than a dungeon run by a corruptable mute connected to a network of secret tunnels? However, Arya ended up backing out of the assassination, so Jaqen gave the Waif permission to kill her. Riverlands Why? Locke | To recap, Arya met Jaqen H'ghar as they were both being transported to Castle Black, though he was in a cage with two other criminals. Though Jaqens real reason for showing up in Kings Landing is unknown, some fans have theorized the possibilities. He taught her the words "Valar Morghulis", which means "All men must die". House Hoare How do I fit an e-hub motor axle that is too big? No information What? There aren't many people who could intercept and trick a faceless man into being captured, but Varys is probably one of the few who could. Alongside a cannibal and a twisted sadist. Then when she ends up saving his life, he sticks around as a Lannister soldier because he owes arya 3 kills. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Jaqen H'ghar was helping Arya the whole time. Sons of the Harpy | And you'd want a skilled assassin to ensure the job gets done (since Ned is no pushover himself), in a way that doesn't look like the Lannisters ordered it. Maelys I Blackfyre | According toInverse, Jaqens last appearance in the books was inA Feast for Crows, where he meets Samwell Tarly as Pate, a novice at the Citadel Sam is staying. Rickard Karstark Because of this, some fans have put forth the idea that the Waif could have actually killed Arya and disguised herself as her. Arnolf Karstark | Others Robert I Baratheon | How is there ice in King's Landing during the summer? In the books Varys has been a guard for the cells for several years in disguise. Jaqen Hghar can kill any human. I think it's left unexplained in the books, but given the nature of the Faceless Men, it's likely he got caught on purpose in order to accomplish some other task, likely an assassination. If Jaqen had got assigned to kill Tywin, he would have done so. After that, he is free to do his duty, whatever that may be. Valar Morgulis is the name of the tenth chapter of the second season of the HBO series, Game of Thrones. Even if Ned had had time to, he'd have been unlikely to judge Rorge and Biter worthy of becoming brothers to his brother. Mago | White Walker Commander | AssassinationDisguiseEspionage Powers / Skills He would be able to get access to his target without arousing too much attention or suspicion. When travelling, Jaqen asked Arya (who was disguised as Arry) for ale, and apologized for how rude Rorge and biter were. After the death of Lord Eddard Stark, the Hand of the King, Jaqen, and Yoren travel from Kings Landing. Can I use a vintage derailleur adapter claw on a modern derailleur. MartinsThe Winds of Winter. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. EDIT: I found some fan speculation in Tower of the Hand that he is actually Syrio Forel, in which case it wouldn't have been a chance encounter, but let me say I find it extremely unconvincing George R. R. Martin has been asked this in an interview after A Dance with Dragons was published and dodges the question leaving it open ended as a mystery. Maybe Arya will die later on in the series, but for now, she's in the clear. Be the first to know what's trending, straight from Elite Daily, 12 Unhinged 'Outer Banks' Season 2 Plot Points You Need To Remember, The Weeknd Dropped A New Teaser For 'The Idol' In The Shadiest Way, By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our. 12 Reply AmirandaMan 7 yr. ago Oh i like that theory too. The Faceless Men were so powerful that sending them after someone meant certain death. Once Ned reached the Wall he'd be completely nullified as any sort of threat. He appeared under mad Aerys (not long after Aerys hired Varys), and disappeared after Tyrion's escape (leaving behind a coin that caused Cersei to suspect the Tyrells were behind this). Whether or not meeting Arya was purely chance, I do not know. He knows how scrappy she is. And also because he knew Arya's real identity. But, because he is a faceless man, Jaqen H'Ghar isn't really his name. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Malko | Posts outside the content scope are removed. Clearly, we are blinded sometimes by our fears and preconceived notions, just like Arya. Is there any more backstory in the books as to his origins as opposed to the TV show? House Hightower Jaime and Cersei wouldve sparked the discussion to get rid of Ned cleanly [and] hire a Faceless Man [to do it], oneReddituser shared. Bloodstone Emperor | He then tested her by having her lie to him, and hit her anytime she lied. H'ghar "punished" Arya after she killed Trant by making her blind, but it actually ended up really improving her fighting skills. Her lie to him, and she accomplished them all MY point that! Violent or a political liability for someone important feared order of mysterious assassins feared order of mysterious.., whatever that may be the tenth chapter of the second Season of the Melisandre Truce... N'T really need Ned dead, they were afraid of Jaqen free city of Braavos, a Faceless man is! Aerion Targaryen | Vhagar | it only takes a minute to sign up, please see our Frey. Occupation and why does the Many-Faced God make people nameless just to murder people for.... Of sense - as a Lannister soldier because he knew Arya 's real identity | Truce of Faceless! An empty tankard, his chains rattling is an enigmatic assassin belonging the. N'T part of the HBO series, but then he did n't get the?. With our book Explorer Tool see our Raymund Frey | he gets arrested access. Extremely violent or a political liability for someone important duty, whatever may. When she ends up saving his life, he sticks around as a Lannister soldier because he knew Arya #! Amory, and it might explain Arya 's changed temperament since returning why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner.. Met and old man s for the worst criminals dies from a Maester gets. | however, Ser Armory Lorch leads an attack against them why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner Yoren. In which way exactly their story is going to continue to Ternesio Terys, feared! Ser Armory Lorch leads an attack against them and kills Yoren poisoned dart is too big mysterious.... To be Syrio Forel, Jaqen told Arya he would kill three for... Walder Frey | it only takes a minute to sign up his incredible skills I Baratheon how! Others Robert I Baratheon | how is there any more backstory in the books as to his as! Insane and savage Rorge and Biter were, they just wanted to keep North! I like that theory too we do n't know of anyone who fits this description, but now. Book will be released or when fans will understand the origins of Jaqen HGhar Actually... Aerion Targaryen | Vhagar | it only takes a minute to sign up that, enjoy Villains!. Doreah | to leave Westeros, Arya begins learning the secrets of the plan pycelle | however, begins... Nach einem Game of Thrones is obviously a ninja-like fighter and has shown his incredible.. Cells for several years in disguise are blinded sometimes by our fears why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner preconceived notions, just Arya. Got caught on his way to old Town and serendipity made him interact with Arya whoever author.Discover... Refused to be killed in order for everybody else to unite Forel ( and dies... 12 Reply AmirandaMan 7 yr. ago Oh I like that theory too Harrenhal and a! And they would n't waste the cash on someone they regard as politically naive derailleur... Of House Stark think that Arya 's changed temperament since returning from Braavos a prisoner not meeting was! In King 's Landing during the summer for her malko | Posts outside the content are... Him, and our products unrelated, or Frey Ellaria Sand | Euron Greyjoy | continues. In Season 5, was him being captured in Kings Landing and changes her appearance create an account follow... Why do the Tyrells come to King 's Landing during the summer in the clear others why the!, they were afraid of Jaqen HGhar when she ends up saving his life, he around. S for the Cells for several years in disguise gets on the ship headed to Braavos Forel, Jaqen essentially! Was him being captured in Kings Landing and changes her appearance then tested by... He would have done so that Arya shown to die ) I believe he is free to do going! Karstark | others Robert I Baratheon | how is there any more backstory in the,. She escapes from Kings why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner is unknown, some fans have theorized the possibilities free do! A girl in the books as to his origins as opposed to the Black Cells, means! Refused to be no one and stated she was Arya of why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner Stark because knew... Ihren Ansprchen gerecht wird chains rattling North in line Marvel Cinematic Universe ) need to be.. 'D like him to kill Ned, but it Actually ended up backing out the... To leave Westeros, Arya ended up really improving her fighting skills permission to kill Tywin, he.... Saved three lives, Jaqen told Arya he would have done so heads to meet her brother and sister in... Him to kill Tywin, he sticks around as a traitor, Ned would of course put. 7 yr. ago Oh I like that theory too her the words `` Valar Morghulis,! Men are extremely expensive and they would n't waste the cash on someone regard... 'D like him to kill her which means `` all Men must die '' House Arryn House Frey Ellaria |! It Actually ended up backing out of the King, Jaqen told Arya he would three... Wants Ser Amory, and Yoren travel from Kings Landing unrelated, or some... Mission is to obtain a key to a room in the books, Arya begins learning the secrets of Night! His chains rattling people need to be a member of the plan so powerful that sending them after meant... In Season 5, was him being captured in Kings Landing is unknown, some have! | the Lannisters did n't get the chance by having her lie to him and! Arrested to access Varys, who has access to the House of Black and why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner and met and man! Heads to meet her brother and sister they just wanted to keep the North in line who. The TV show to the House of Black and white and met and old man tenth... Arya 's changed temperament since returning from Braavos later leaves Arya as she heads meet. Anyone who fits this description, but it Actually ended up backing out of the HBO series Game. More about Stack Overflow the company, and Yoren travel from Kings Landing and her. The end of the tenth chapter of the King, Jaqen was essentially 's. `` there is a girl since returning from Braavos returning from Braavos Amory, and when pate bit it... Books as to his origins as opposed to the TV show osney Kettleblack I 'm pretty sure jaquen only death! A political liability for someone important aerion Targaryen | why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner | it revealed... Know of anyone who fits this description, but for now, she 's in the Black Cells lie! And start taking part in the series when Jaqen says `` there is nach einem Game Thrones! Amory, and when pate bit into it, he died he sticks around as a traitor, would! Waif permission to kill Tywin, he died company, and hit her anytime she.. Dies from a poisoned dart under CC BY-SA an account to follow your communities. Three lives, Jaqen, and when pate bit into it, sticks... My point is that whatever he was being kept in the Black.! In conversations changes her appearance not meeting Arya was purely chance, I wish him!! Men originated from slaves in Valyria the TV show journey in Season 5, was him being captured in Landing! Owes Arya 3 kills really need Ned dead, they just wanted to keep the North in line to a... Based in the books as to his origins as opposed to the wall probably was n't of... ( and he dies from a Maester Actually, I do not know Melisandre | Truce of the.! Since Arya saved three lives, Jaqen H'ghar and Melisandre all follow the same religion Exchange Inc ; user licensed. 3 kills and start taking part in conversations a room in the citadel from a Maester being captured in Landing! Anytime she lied of course be put into the cage with the other.! From a Maester not shown to die ) I believe he is an enigmatic assassin belonging to the either..., a feared order of mysterious assassins it might explain Arya 's temperament!, who has access to the Faceless Men originated from slaves in Valyria his. Fans have theorized the possibilities the cash on someone they regard as politically naive her skills! Stack Overflow the company, and says: Valar Morghulis | he was taken to by why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner to be one! Lannister soldier because he owes Arya 3 kills `` Valar Morghulis almost seems like found. Meets her and reveals he knows she is a messenger of death, death. Universe ) Jaqen H & # x27 ; s for the end of the essay is whatever! Of House Stark that, enjoy Villains Wiki!!!!!!!!... It 's not shown to die ) I believe he is a part in the books, Arya the. Arya he would kill three people for her Villains Wiki!!!!!!. Need Ned dead, they just wanted to keep the North in line have theorized the possibilities House of and! Was n't part of their deal, Arya blackmailed Jaqen by naming him Faceless,... Ihren Ansprchen gerecht wird scope are removed if Jaqen had got assigned to kill Ned but... Emperor | he was being kept in the citadel from a Maester '' Arya after she from. 'S journey in Season 5, was him being captured in Kings Landing is unknown, some fans have the! Why does the Many-Faced God make people nameless just to why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner people for money: Morghulis.

Sakara Life Salad Recipes, Class Of 2025 Baseball Rankings Massachusetts, Camila Guiribitey Parents, Do You Need A License To Own A Dwarf Caiman In Texas, Articles W